PURE NINJA / PN-G007
Comparing two INCI lists: a practical worksheet
Match the product versions, copy exact ingredient names and separate visible differences from guesses about performance.
Start with a narrow question
Two ingredient lists can answer a narrow question: which names appear in each text? They cannot, on their own, tell you which product will work better for you. Keep this distinction visible at the top of your comparison rather than turning the exercise into a score.
Use this worksheet when comparing products or checking a possible change to a familiar product. The result should be a traceable note, with sources and unanswered questions. It is not a diagnosis, a safety ranking or a reconstruction of the manufacturer’s formula.
Match the product versions
Record the exact product name and version before comparing. Include the shade or variant, the market shown by the source and the date you checked it. A similar bottle or a shared brand name is not enough to establish that two lists describe the same item.
Keep a readable package photo and the URL of any online list. If they disagree, label the sources separately and ask the manufacturer which list applies to the product you have. Do not combine them into a new list that appears nowhere on either source.
Copy names without shortening
Transcribe each ingredient name in full and keep the original order. FDA explains that ingredient naming follows labeling rules and that international labeling can require attention to names. [1] Treat an unfamiliar spelling as something to check, not a word to silently replace.
Use one ingredient per row. Preserve numbers, prefixes and parentheses from the source. If you use a scan or text recognition, compare the result with the photo: a missing character can create a false difference. Put uncertain readings in a separate column rather than guessing.
Separate matches from questions
Create three groups: the same written name in both lists, names found only in A, and names found only in B. Add a fourth group for unresolved spelling or naming differences. An exact text match is a useful observation; a non-match is not automatically proof of a different substance.
You may standardise spaces for easier reading, but retain the original text beside your working copy. Do not merge names merely because they share a word. Record a possible synonym as a question until a reliable source or the manufacturer resolves it.
Try a fictional comparison
Consider these deliberately incomplete teaching fragments: A contains Glycerin and Panthenol; B contains Glycerin and Niacinamide. The written match is Glycerin. Panthenol occurs only in fragment A and Niacinamide only in fragment B. These are text observations, not complete cosmetic formulas.
A useful note reads: “These fragments share one exact name; each has one other name.” It does not read: “B is stronger” or “A is safer”. Open the ingredient index to learn about the names, but keep those explanations separate from evidence about either finished product.
Do not calculate percentages from position
Keep position as a separate observation, not an estimated concentration. FDA’s U.S. labeling guide describes descending order with exceptions, including ingredients at no more than one percent and color additives. [2] This is a U.S. example of why a list is not a percentage table; do not apply its legal wording indiscriminately to every market.
Even identical names in identical order do not provide all concentrations or prove equal performance. Likewise, a moved name does not reveal how large a change is. If a precise percentage matters, look for a specific manufacturer statement and record its source and scope.
Finish with a limited conclusion
Save the two sources, exact matches, differences and questions. Write a conclusion that stays within the evidence: “The lists differ in these written entries; the reason has not been confirmed.” Ask the manufacturer about the exact version if the discrepancy affects your decision.
Use Pure Ninja to explore ingredient names and functions. For claims about a complete product, return to its instructions and supporting evidence. A comparison is useful when it makes uncertainty visible, not when it hides unknown details behind a similarity score.