PURE NINJA / PN-G003
Beyond the ingredient list: how to check a cosmetic claim
A practical worksheet for separating names, product promises and evidence without turning an INCI list into a performance score.
Read the question before the list
You have found two creams with Glycerin on their labels. One says “lightweight”, the other mentions lasting hydration. Does their shared ingredient settle which one matches those descriptions? Start by writing the question you actually want answered. Reading a name, comparing texture and checking a duration claim are different tasks.
Use three columns: what the package says, what information supports it, and what remains unknown. Keep the full product name, market and a photograph of the current package above the table. This makes it easier to notice when a retailer’s description refers to a different version rather than treating every online sentence as information about your own jar.
Name the exact promise
Copy one product claim before trying to evaluate it. “Contains Glycerin” and “feels light” call for different checks. The first directs you to the label; the second prompts questions about how that impression was assessed. Do not silently replace a narrow statement with a larger promise such as “will work better for me”.
EU criteria require evidence when ingredient properties are extended to a finished-product claim. [1] For your worksheet, place an ingredient reference and a product study in separate rows. This is an educational reading exercise, not a legal assessment of the advertisement.
Identify what was tested
Ask whether the evidence concerns the ingredient or the finished product. Read the actual product name in the material provided. If it is missing, write “identity unclear” rather than assuming the test used the cream in front of you. A matching keyword is a starting point for checking, not the end of the check.
As a concrete reading example, Vaillant and colleagues compared a complete cream with formulation variants. [2] Open the abstract and locate the methods before the conclusion. Practise identifying the test material. You do not need to rank the products or transfer the study’s outcome to your own cream to learn from that step.
Match the result to the question
Record what was measured and when it was measured. A statement about how a product feels and a numerical measurement deserve separate lines in your notes. Preserve the units, time point and comparison stated in the report. If one is absent from the short summary, mark it as unreported there.
Try rewriting a vague note such as “tested, so effective” as questions: tested for which outcome, compared with what, after which use? Do not fill the gaps with a percentage copied from a different product. A careful question is more useful than a precise-looking number with no clear source.
Work through a fictional example
Imagine a fictional cream called A with a claim of a “light feel” and a user questionnaire. Another fictional cream, B, gives an instrument measurement after a stated interval. No real products or results are represented here. Write the claim and the evidence type for each without awarding points.
Now ask whether either description answers the same question. If your question is about feel, note what the questionnaire actually asked. If it is about a measured change, identify that measurement. You may end with two incomplete records rather than a winner. That is a valid outcome of the exercise, not a reason to invent a comparison.
Close the worksheet with a next step
Choose one real product, one exact claim and one linked source. Write down the test identity, the reported outcome and the timing if available. Add a single unresolved question you could ask the manufacturer, such as whether the supplied result concerns the current product version. Keep unanswered fields visibly blank.
Use the ingredient index below for names and typical roles, then return to the product-level question. Your notes should distinguish a label observation, a reference description and a measured result. They do not establish personal tolerance, diagnose a reaction or replace the product instructions.